虎扑体育网
搜我想看打开APP
抬区关于信息源可信度的分档，以供参考（ZT）
1.有个别分档有争议，仅供参考。
2.并不是名气大的信息源就权威，有些媒体有自己的立场。
例如法国队报（L'Equipe），作为金球奖的创办方，地位很高。然而由于立场原因，队报报道巴黎相关的新闻非常不靠谱，曾由于多次新闻造假被巴黎禁止参加记者会。如果队报说我抬球员要去巴黎，或者巴黎球员想来我抬，不要盲信。
3.权威媒体的不同记者可信度也不同。
例如天空体育被分到了T4（无直接信息来源，低可信度）。然而天空体育的部分记者如Andy Burton，James Cooper等被分到了T2（近期被证实有内部消息来源）。天空体育作为正经媒体，一般来讲他们说实锤了就真的实锤了。尽管实锤的时间也相对其他信息源滞后，但翻车情况比较少。当天空体育无依据地瞎编和猜测的时候（他们也要吃饭的），会注明自己的新闻没有源头，纯猜测。这点强于厕纸报，因为厕纸报会说“据内部消息”“据身边人/朋友/亲戚/队友透露”等等，显得自己很有料。 天空体育的新闻里出现"understands"就是记者的个人见解，没有消息来源，也不必为此负责。毕竟"understands"嘛，我还可以理解梅西是儿魔梦准备夏窗转会曼联呢。除了个别记者的"understands"有参考价值，其他的跟ESPN、地铁报、镜报、邮报的新闻也差不多。
4.有些厕纸报里也有个别靠谱记者。
例如通常来讲ESPN和太阳报一样属于厕纸范围（T5,专门造谣生事或者被禁止的信息源），但是ESPN的个别记者还是有一定可信度的。
5.权威媒体有的时候也会转发厕纸信息。
例如BBC专门有个Football Gossip的区，用来转发其他媒体的新闻，不代表BBC的立场。不要看到BBC发的就觉得可信，看看下面有没有 Gossip 的标签，可能是BBC转的太阳报。
6.信息源分档有时效性。
例于西班牙的COPE走了一些记者后，就没有很多内部消息了，可信度也下降。都灵体育99%的时间都是厕纸报，但是有个别的时候确实有内部消息。
| Tier | Source |
|---|---|
| Tier 0 (Undisputed, Official Sources) | @ManUtd / manutd.com |
| Tier 1 (Highest Quality Sources) | Simon Stone (BBC) / Sport1 (Germany) / Henry Winter (The Times Chief of Football) / Mohamed Bouhafsi (France) / Fabrizio Romano (Guardian) / Paul Joyce (The Times/Liverpool/Everton) / David Ornstein (BBC/Arsenal) / Craig Norwood (Club Photographer) / Kristof Terreur (The Guardian) / Gianluca Di Marzio (Italians only, Tier 2 if not) / Simon Peach (Press Association) |
| Tier 2 (Proven to have current sources) | Bild (Germany/Bavaria) / Der Westen (Germany/Schalke/Gladbach/Dortmund) / Kicker (Germany) / De Telegraaf (Netherlands) / COPE (Spain) / Raphael Honigstein (Germany Freelancer/Guardian German News) / Voetbal International (Netherlands) / Matt Law (Telegraph/Chelsea) / Andy Burton (Sky Sports) / Caderna SER (Spain) / O Jogo (Portugal) / James Cooper (Sky Sports) / RMC Sport (France) / BBC (United Kingdom) |
| Tier 3 (Average reliability, or former Tier 2) | Canal+/Pierre Menes (France) / Jamie Jackson (Guardian) / Ian Ladyman (Daily Mail) / The Telegraph / The Guardian / The Times / Mark Ogden (ESPN) / Daniel Taylor(Guardian) / Correio de Manha (Portugal) / Ruhr Nachrichten (Germany) / Le Parisien (France) / Ian Herbert (Independent) / Jason Burt (Telegraph) / Record (Portugal) / A Bola(Portugal) / Richard Keys (beIN Sports) / Jim White (Everton only) / L'Equipe (France) / Paul Hirst (The Times) / James Ducker (the Telegraph) / Rob Dawson (ESPN) |
| Tier 4 (Indirect sources, low reliability) | BildSport (Germany) / Tuttomercatoweb (Italy) / Sport (Spain) / Goal.com / Guillem Balague (Sky Sports/Freelance) / Stuart Mathieson (MEN) / The Independent / Mundo Deportivo (Spain) / Marca (Spain/Real Madrid) / AS (Spain/Real Madrid) / Talksport (UK & Ireland) / Sky Sports / Kaveh Solhekol (Sky Sports) / Stephen Howson (FullTimeDevils) / Paris/Euro United (France/PSG) / Simon Mullock (Mirror) / London Evening Standard / Daily Mail / The Mirror / John Cross (The Mirror) / Steve Bates (Mirror) / Duncan Castles (Record/Times) / CalcioMercato (Italy) / El Chiringuito (Unless J. Sanchez, then T1) |
| Tier 5 (Aggregators, Known Shitposters and Banned sources) | Peter O'Rouke (Freelance) / Tancredi Palmieri (Freelance/Bullshit merchant) / Metro (banned - utter shit) / Express (banned - redditwide ban due to vote manipulation) / The Sun(Banned - for being the Sun) / Diario Gol (Spain) / Daily Star (Go there for tits, not news) / CaughtOffside (Aggregates, but poses the news as its own) / Don Balon (Spain) / Samuel Luckhurst (M.E.N - Shit-stirring bellend.) / Squawka (Vote Manipulation) / Sport/LAD Bible (Clickbait merchants/Content thieves) / Joe.co.uk (Shit memes and even worse transfer content) / 90min.com / Andy Mitten (Transfer News) / Miguel Delaney (Transfer News Only) / ESPN (except for articles by Delaney, Mitten, Dawson and Ogden) / Manchester Evening News / Sport Witness (aggregator) / Newsnow (aggregator) /@CheGiaevara (aggregator) / GFFN (France/aggregator) / Here is the City (Aggregator) / Bleacher Report(Aggregator) / 90 min.com (Aggregator)/ All Other Aggregators / Football365 (Transfer News) / SportsMole (Shit source) |
| Tier IndyKaila | This guy is worse than an unknown entity. In fact, his Twitter account is so bad, that Russia considered making a Space Station out of it. This tier is also known as Tier Kohler and includes fans of Toilets and Sink-makers... |
发布于北京阅读 6164
这些回复亮了
天涯降龙枪
· 陕西报纸说什么都可以，我觉得OK，人毕竟要挣钱，但是你啥都信，那就是真的瞎了。。。。。。。。。。。。。
亮了(26)
回复
ccryan1
· 上海感谢楼主，本来我也想发一个差不多的贴，但是没有这份全且有出入。例如迪马特奥报意大利有关的准，但是其他国家的不一定。我来凭记忆说点最近（两周内）我在reddit上看到的转会新闻可信度吧1. 波霸大部分新闻 (tier 3 及 tier 3以下）, 除了尤文想买 (tier 1) 2. 有意埃里克森 (tier 2)3. 关注穆尼尔 (tier 1，2）4. 热刺想35m卖特里皮尔 （tier 1）5. 埃雷拉意向离队 (tier 1 及以下）6. 几家俱乐部（曼联在内）有意菲利克斯 (tier 1）请大家指正
亮了(17)
回复