分享一个外网评论
I am also old enough & I gotta say. I HONESTLY thought Jokić was the best player that I have ever seen both with the eye test, stats & advanced stats & i had that discussion quite carefully with my father at first the year Jokić got his first MVP but before he ever won it or we knew. It was still early. So I felt that way long before he was considered by most, "the best on the planet". My 70 year old father who's still clear as day felt the same way. And he got to see the 🐐's before those guys' time! The Adrian Dantleys, The Fat Levers & The 4x MVP & legend, Wilt Chamberlains & Oscar Robinsons. And in Wilts case, Joker is doing things that have never been done since Wilt or ever for that matter and not just one or two things. As well as its its not just some random record or best stat, it's the entirety of them including their bag, opponents, styles & Era which kinda go together. I don't factor the Titles AS much as some weigh them. It's not that I necessarily discount them. I just gotta be real. Jokers not playing with MJ's squad or with Lebron or Kobe's squads including super teams or pairings. You might argue he has Jamal and his starting 5 is arguably the best starting 5 in today's recent years or at least top 3/top 5, but he's never even played with another all-star, EVER. The on off stats as everyone knows especially are just insane when Joker is on or off the floor & he's playing his whole career in a fly-over city that had never won a title before he came and delivered the first in 47 YEARS! So I almost weigh his one as a two or three but I honestly feel that even if you took titles completely out or evened them up, Joker is just better at SO much more and let me say...MJ, Lebron, Kobe and the legends (if on equal footing) have HUGE bags too. But they are not really an all positions player or a 7 footer that plays with the mind and skills of not just a big man or a wing, but as the usual smallest and/or best handling play making guard type of mind that Jokić plays with. They either have one or the other & then a solid bag of tricks and skills based on that position. It's rare to see a guy that looks like him, pass & have the vision like magic, shoot like MJ or Bird even at 3pt%, dominate the post like Shaq, Duncan, the great Hakeem Olajuwon or Kareem while having an absolute elite level Court Mapping skill unlike anyone really for the levek its at but id put in guys like Magic, Kobe & Lebron but even Lebron thinks Jokić court maps st a level unlike amy other, has an extra shot named after him like Dirk(the somber shuffle), Dominates the playoffs like MJ and way better in the playoffs than Bird so you could argue he's got a clutch game like any if the best including MJ and probably more I'm not thinking of. Sorry. Old & terminally ill. Brain fog is killer.
See, I say all this but it sounds kinda like I'm trying to pull someone down, but I actually feel very similar to you guys as far as putting those guys at the top. It's just for me, who's seen every Jordan game, Every Jokić game & a metric F ton of Bird, Kobe & Lebron as well. I just cannot watch all of every one of those guys but that's ok. I saw enough of Birds peak, the best of Kobe & still watch Lebron of course. I just personally feel that Jokić is not just the greatest player I feel I have EVER seen if you take into account everything and you somehow equal up their teams/titles only because we're not talking about the singular player with those. You can, but you can't win a title by yourself (unless you count zero other Allstars but even then...its just hard to put a legitimate value on those because they are vastly different in many ways. But boil it down to season & post season personal stats, advanced metrics & eye test, I put Jokić at the very top by a slim but bigger margin than you might think especially after this year! I've been saying he cannot get ANY better EVERY year but he finds a way to out do himself & add SOMETHING more to his already ginormous bag of skills & shots...you add in the IQ ...man. I dunno.
I wouldn't sit and argue with either one of you guys that replied, I'd just say we agree to disagree although we have them up there together for sure. I just personally feel that Nikola Jokić, even moreso as a player drafted where he was during a taco bell commercial and was asleep when it happened, is the best IVE ever seen play the entire game of basketball as well as have the basketball IQ of a genius unlike anyone. Who literally knows and sees things happen before they happen & will often times put his teammates in the exact place as well as direct them to do a certain thing or look for it being another coach on the floor. He'll even draw up plays all while also being the most humble man I've seen. I mean, basketball is just a job for him and he's not looking for the spotlight, the spotlight looks for him, the fat kid who drank a liter of coca-cola every day but transformed himself into not just the greatest story
以下豆包翻译
我也年纪不小了,不得不说,我真心认为约基奇是我见过的最出色的球员,无论是通过肉眼观察、常规数据统计,还是高阶数据统计来评判。在约基奇首次获得最有价值球员(MVP)的那一年,甚至在他真正获奖或者大家都意识到他的实力之前,我就和我父亲认真地讨论过这个问题。那时候还很早呢。所以在大多数人认为他是 “地球上最优秀的球员” 之前很久,我就有这种感觉了。我70岁的父亲,头脑依然十分清醒,他也有同样的看法。而且他还见证过那些在约基奇之前的传奇人物打球!比如阿德里安・丹特利、“胖子” 利弗斯,还有那位四届MVP得主、传奇人物威尔特・张伯伦以及奥斯卡・罗伯特森。就张伯伦的情况而言,约基奇正在做一些自张伯伦之后就再也没人做到过的事情,甚至可以说在整个篮球历史上都没人做到过,而且还不只是一两件事。这也不只是一些随意的记录或者某项最佳数据,而是涵盖了所有方面,包括他们的技术特点、面对的对手、比赛风格以及所处的时代,这些因素都是相互关联的。
和有些人特别看重总冠军戒指不同,我没有把它看得那么重。不是说我完全不考虑总冠军的因素,只是我得实事求是。约基奇可没有像迈克尔・乔丹、勒布朗・詹姆斯或者科比・布莱恩特那样的阵容,也没有和超级球队或者巨星搭档合作过。你可能会说他有贾马尔(穆雷),而且他所在的首发五虎可以说是近年来最好的,至少能排进前三或者前五,但他从来没有和另一位全明星球员一起打过球。众所周知,当约基奇在场和不在场时,球队的 “正负值” 数据简直太惊人了。而且他整个职业生涯都在一座此前从未拿过总冠军的城市打球,在他到来后,这座城市47年来首次捧起了总冠军奖杯!所以我几乎把他的这一个总冠军当作两三个来衡量,但说实话,我觉得即使完全不考虑总冠军,或者让总冠军数量对等,约基奇在很多方面也更加出色。我想说的是…… 乔丹、詹姆斯、科比以及那些传奇球星(如果在同等条件下)也都有非常出色的表现。但他们并不是真正意义上的能打所有位置的球员,也不是身高七英尺(约2.13米)却有着不只是内线球员或者锋线球员的思维和技术的球员,约基奇打球时有着像最出色的控球后卫一样的思维,而且通常是场上最矮小或者控球最好、传球组织能力最强的球员。那些传奇球星要么有这方面的能力,要么有那方面的能力,然后基于他们的位置拥有一套扎实的技术和技巧。很少能看到像他这样的球员,传球视野像魔术师约翰逊一样出色,三分球命中率像迈克尔・乔丹或者拉里・伯德一样高,在内线统治力上像沙奎尔・奥尼尔、蒂姆・邓肯、伟大的哈基姆・奥拉朱旺或者卡里姆(阿卜杜尔-贾巴尔)一样强,同时还拥有绝对顶级的球场局势判断能力,在这个层面上几乎无人能及。我觉得魔术师约翰逊、科比和詹姆斯在这方面也很出色,但就连勒布朗也认为约基奇在球场局势判断上有着与众不同的水平。约基奇还有一个像德克(诺维茨基)的 “金鸡独立” 一样以他名字命名的独特招式(约基奇的 “梦幻脚步”),在季后赛中的统治力像迈克尔・乔丹一样强,而且在季后赛中的表现比拉里・伯德要好得多,所以你可以说他和最出色的球员一样关键,可能还有很多我没想到的优点。抱歉,我年纪大了,还身患绝症,头脑犯糊涂的感觉太难受了。
你看,我说了这么多,但听起来好像我在试图贬低其他球员似的。但实际上,在把那些传奇球星放在顶尖位置这一点上,我的想法和你们大多数人很相似。只是对我来说,我看过乔丹的每一场比赛、约基奇的每一场比赛,也看了大量伯德、科比和詹姆斯的比赛。我不可能看完他们每个人的所有比赛,但这也没关系。我见证了伯德的巅峰时期,看过科比最精彩的表现,当然也还在关注詹姆斯的比赛。我只是个人觉得,如果综合考虑所有因素,并且在某种程度上让他们的球队阵容和总冠军数量对等的话(因为我们讨论的不只是单个球员,还涉及到这些因素),约基奇不只是我见过的最伟大的球员。你可以只考虑单个球员,但你不可能仅凭自己赢得总冠军(除非你把没有其他全明星队友也算在内,但即便如此…… 也很难给这些因素赋予一个确切的价值,因为它们在很多方面都有很大的不同)。但如果把标准简化为常规赛和季后赛的个人数据、高阶数据统计以及肉眼观察,我认为约基奇处于最顶尖的位置,而且领先优势虽然不大,但比你想象的要大,尤其是在今年之后!我每年都说他不可能变得更出色了,但他总是能找到超越自己的方法,为他那已经非常丰富的技术和进攻手段再增添一些新东西…… 再加上他的球商…… 天哪,我也说不清楚。
对于之前回复我的人,我不会坐下来和你们争论,我只会说我们求同存异,不过我们肯定都认为这些球员都很优秀。我只是个人觉得,尼古拉・约基奇,尤其是考虑到他是在一个塔可钟(快餐品牌)广告时段被选中的,被选中时他还在睡觉,从这个角度来说,他是我见过的在整个篮球比赛中表现最出色的球员,而且他拥有天才般的篮球智商,无人能及。他真的能在事情发生之前就预见到,而且经常能把队友放到最恰当的位置,指导他们做特定的事情或者寻找机会,就像球场上的另一个教练。他甚至还能布置战术,同时他又是我见过的最谦逊的人。我的意思是,篮球对他来说只是一份工作,他并不追求聚光灯,而是聚光灯主动找上他。这个曾经每天喝一升可口可乐的胖小子,不仅实现了最伟大的蜕变……
tony1444
· 湖北别人怎么觉得不在乎,我也肯定不是约的球迷,反正约基奇是我见过最强的篮球天才
墨水很蓝哇
· 浙江看得泪花出来了